« Kahle v. Ashcroft appealed | Main | Core copyright principles and the threat to innovation »

Garret the copyright propagandist

Garrett_the_ferrett

PR Newswire: "Garret" is the name children selected for the "copyright crusading" ferret, who is featured in "Copyright Crusader to the Rescue."

Having a corporate-sponsored comic book is fine, I suppose, but incorporating this one-sided, misleading propagandist claptrap into the teaching curriculum is an outrage.

Here's the teachers guide and elementary and high school posters (in French, too!).

Also, here's Garret solo. See the full comic here. Sort of a "Reefer Madness" for the digital age, no?

From the release:

The "Copyright Crusader to the Rescue" is the newest addition to BSA's cyber ethics education program. The curriculum was developed to teach children about cyber ethics, including the importance of responsible computer and Internet use, respect for digital creativity and copyright protection. ...

In addition to being available for free download at http://www.playitcybersafe.com, the four-page comic book curriculum and teacher's guide were also mailed nationwide to 30,000 fourth grade teachers who subscribe to Weekly Reader. It has also reached more than one million kids and two million parents and guardians. Also available for free download on the Play It Cyber Safe Web site is BSA's first cyber ethics curriculum, "Play It Safe in Cyberspace." Since its initial distribution in 2002, the "Play It Safe in Cyberspace" curriculum has reached more than 13 million kids, parents and teachers.

Somebody -- the EFF? Creative Commons? -- needs to step up, set the record straight, and add some nuance to this discussion. Will the words "fair use" ever pass the lips of the instructors in this program? Will kids be taught that sharing music with a friend is perfectly legal? Not by the look of things.

February 8, 2005 at 05:13 PM in Education | Permalink | Comments (4) | Bookmark this entry on del.icio.us | blog comments on this post (3)

» Refer Madness from Joho the Blog
JD Lasica pastes Garrett the Copyright Totalitarian Ferret Who The Kids Love right in his snot-filled little nose.... [Read More]

Tracked on Feb 9, 2005 8:34:27 AM

» Copyright Education: Harder Than It Looks from Freedom to Tinker
This afternoon I'm going to lead a discussion among twenty-five bright Princeton students, about the basics of copyright. Why do we have copyright? Why does it cover expression and not ideas? Why fair use? The answers are subtle, but I hope to guide th... [Read More]

Tracked on Feb 9, 2005 8:47:40 AM

» Garret the Ferret: Brainwashing the Young About Copyright from Get Real
JD Lasica pulls down the pants of a Business Software Alliance campaign using a comic book ferret, Garret, to instill all sorts of pernicious notions about copyright and "cybercrime". This is targeted at grade school kids, note. David Weinberger's one... [Read More]

Tracked on Feb 10, 2005 6:39:22 AM

Comments

Exactly my thoughts on the issue. Making the propaganda of a lobbying group part of school's curriculum is morally repulsive. Though a counter-weasel by the EFF/CC might be an idea, I think generally children should be free from any coloured, non-objective teachings. The sad thing is that here (The Netherlands) the local BSA has come up with an even more agressive campaign, featuring an all-seeing pig and a mob squat roaming the streets in search for young infringers. The tactics of intimidation & fear, even less pretty than mis-education.

Posted by: Rik Lambers | Feb 9, 2005 1:56:28 PM

Downhill Battle is taking on the weasel at their Kids Smell Bullshit web site, which includes a Wiki for developing responses to BSA classroom propaganda. See also the CopyTeach project.

Posted by: Tim Armstrong | Feb 10, 2005 9:45:02 AM

Something must be wrong with me because I didn't find the cartoon repulsive at all. What's the complaint here? That it is OK to copy software your friend bought and use it? Cool. That will save me a lot of money.

Posted by: Don Park | Feb 13, 2005 8:10:58 PM

The problem is the one-sided nature of a complex issue that almost certainly does not deserve to be reduced to the "sharing = bad" meme that will be employed at the grade school level.

Posted by: JD | Feb 17, 2005 2:08:45 AM

Post a comment

(Because of spam, comments are held for approval by JD. Please hit Post only once.)